Pens win the cup Follow This Pens fall to Sens 2-1 in OT of Game 1 Twitter May 14 2017 · 5:00 am May 14 2017 · 5:00 am follow story share Share Tweet Email The Penguins scored late to tie it, but the Senators scored in OT to steal Game 1 at the Paint Can. Tweet from @NHL × facebook twitter linkedin email × Follow this story For updates, please enter your email address and we'll send you important developments as they happen. What is the current year? Leave this field blank. Follow × Thank you! Please check your email to confirm your subscription to “Pens win the cup” You'll get emails from The Incline as this story develops. You can unsubscribe in every email.