Four One Brew

‘Same burgers, same brunch, same people. Just better beer:’ North Side Benjamin’s to become Bier’s Pub

The pub will be home to the long-awaited War Streets Taproom, and it’s getting a “Bier Garden” out back.

In 2013, Jake Bier won a homebrewing competition at Wigle Whiskey in Spring Garden. Soon, he'll open the next North Side craft brewery in Allegheny West.

In 2013, Jake Bier won a homebrewing competition at Wigle Whiskey in Spring Garden. Soon, he'll open the next North Side craft brewery in Allegheny West.

Chris Togneri / For The Incline

Well, that took a while.

Jake Bier has known for years that he wanted to open a brewery, and when he signed a lease in 2014 on the old Arch Street Firehouse in the Mexican War Streets, he thought he’d found a home for it. In fact, he told me that November that he would open War Streets Brewery by the spring of 2015.

But as any craft brewer in Pittsburgh will tell you: It always takes longer than expected.

Jake Bier planned to open his War Streets Brewery in this old firehouse on Arch Street. Instead, he will open on Western Avenue In the space now occupied by Benjamin's.

This is the firehouse that was almost home to the War Streets Taproom.

Chris Togneri / For The Incline

“Just one roadblock after another,” said Bier, a War Streets resident. “But this is a blessing in disguise. Now we can be here, in a business that’s already established and successful and with a landlord that wants this to work.”

The established and successful business Bier speaks of is Benjamin’s, a burger, beer and brunch joint on Western Avenue.

Bier worked there as a bartender for about a year and a half. So when he heard the owner was looking to sell, he pitched his boss on the idea of selling to him.

The owner was on board, Bier got a loan, and they closed the deal last week. Occupancy permit now in hand, Bier finally has home for his beer.

“We’ll keep it as Benjamin’s for now because so many people are familiar with it, and it’s a got a great reputation,” Bier said over an IPA at the Allegheny West spot last week. “But eventually we will rebrand as Bier’s Pub, home to the War Streets Taproom.”

Little else will change. The burger menu — popular among North Siders and highly-rated by others online — will stay the same, as will the brunch menu and staff, according to Bier and pub co-owner Abbey Surrena.

“Same burgers, same brunch, same people,” he said. “Just better beer.”

Over time Bier will add a “Bier Garden” out back and a new bar on the upper first level, but the renovations will not require closures, Bier said. Work is likely to begin after the NFL season ends, he added, as Benjamin’s is typically “crushed” on Steeler Sundays.

Now looking forward, Bier is reluctant to look back.

Asked about the firehouse location, he shrugged. Landlord dispute, he explained. The building is 140 years old, and the work Bier and his business partner, Zach Ingoldsby, proposed turned out to be too ambitious for the owner’s taste.

Still, Bier wants to maintain the War Streets connection, so his beers will keep their War Streets-flavored names: Arch Street Amber Ale, Buena Vista Brown Ale, Monterey IPA, Palo Alto Pale Ale, Resaca Red Ale and Sherman Avenue Stout. (Last time I interviewed him, I had the stout, and it was special with perfect malt levels and a silky mouthfeel.)

Beer at the War Streets Taproom will be named after streets in the North Side neighborhood and  Allegheny West.

Beer at the War Streets Taproom will be named after streets in the North Side neighborhood and Allegheny West.

Chris Togneri / For The Incline

“Now we have opportunities to name beers after these streets (in Allegheny West),” Bier said. “Lincoln Avenue Lager, Galveston Gold, Western Wheat … There’s a bunch of new names I can come up with now.”

It’s been a long time coming, and Bier admits he did not expect the process to take this long.

Nobody ever does.

Just ask the owners of Allegheny City Brewing, who expected a March 2016 opening but settled on September.

Or the folks at Eleventh Hour Brewing Co. in Lawrenceville, who planned to open last fall, but still haven’t. (Note: They’re getting awfully close, so expect details in this space soon.)

Did Bier, who studied contemporary music, consider giving up?

“Sure. Yeah,” he said. “But what else am I going to do? This is what I want to do.”

Abbey Surrena and Jake Bier, co-owners of Bier's Pub — which will open in the space that is today occupied by Benjamin's in Allegheny West — say the menu will stay the same, but the beer will be better.

Bier's Pub co-owners Abbey Surrena and Jake Bier say the menu will stay the same, but the beer will be better.

Chris Togneri / For The Incline

He would have done things differently. He wouldn’t have quit a salaried job at Rosedale Technical College until he was absolutely ready to open. And maybe he would have mapped out a more realistic timeline and been better prepared for the rigors of self-employment.

“I used to think: Why would anybody want to work a desk job for somebody else?” Bier said. “Now I see, well, you work eight hours a day, and then you’re done. You go home, and you do whatever you want with your family, and you’re not thinking about work.

“But when you do this, every day you’re creating your situation. You don’t have to answer to anyone else, so that’s the positive side of it. But it never stops. You never clock out. You’re always thinking about the next thing.”

It’s been a “hell of a process — really, really stressful,” he said.

But now comes the fun part:

Making and selling his own beer.

“The scariness versus the reward — I still haven’t gotten the reward,” he says. “But I think this will pay off.”

He sips his beer, then added:

“It better.”

Chris Togneri won first place for humor writing from the National Guild of Beer Writers after he ‘fixed’ Mayor Bill Peduto’s terrible beer taste in 2015. The mayor is reportedly drinking Miller Lite again, so … the struggle continues.

Want some more? Explore other Four One Brew stories.

We love you, Pittsburgh.

Looks like you’re the type of person who reads to the end of articles.

Because you love learning about Pittsburgh, you need our free morning newsletter, full of useful news, can’t-miss events, and everything else you need to know about our city.

There's no journalism without u.

Reporting and writing stories like this require time — and money. When readers like you become members, it ensures that we’ll be able to keep bringing you the news. Will you join us today?

It feels like we know each other.

It’s nice seeing you here, because we can’t do this without you.

Make our relevant, original, and actionable journalism possible by contributing now.

Let’s make it official.

Your support allows us to do great work like the article you just read, and we can’t do it without you.

Will you become a member today to help us for the long haul?

You’re the best.

Members often ask us how they can go the extra mile to help us. Your financial support makes this possible. Bringing your friends makes it fun.

Get your loved ones to sign up for our daily newsletter today.