Ultimate Fish Fry

Vote for the 2018 Ultimate Pittsburgh Fish Fry in The Incline’s NCAA-style bracket

Narrow the field from 32 to 16 by Monday, Feb. 19.

Fish Fry w: logo
The Incline Illustration
MJ Slaby

Update, 10 a.m. Feb. 19: Voting for this round has closed.

We asked and you didn’t disappoint — nearly 250 nominations rolled in for this year’s Ultimate Pittsburgh Fish Fry bracket.

Competition will be tough. There are multiple repeats from last year’s bracket, including three of the Final Four — Holy Angels, St. Joan of Arc and Corpus Christi. Rounding out that group was St. Alphonsus, last year’s champ, which we said couldn’t compete this year. (Here’s how they responded to that, btw.)

But there are also some newcomers with strong followings and multiple nominations. We seeded competitors based on number of nominations and nominators’ zeal in describing the fish fry. But seeding isn’t the end-all-be-all. Last year’s winner was seeded 7th, so it’s really all about the votes.

Fish Fry two
The Incline illustration

Here’s the breakdown:

  • Top left quadrant: Fire Halls and Social Clubs. Fire halls will face fire halls and likewise with the social clubs, until the Elite Eight, when the top in each category will face off for a spot in the Final Four.
  • Bottom left quadrant: Eateries. This quadrant is for cafes, bars, restaurants and so on.
  • Top right quadrant: Churches West.
  • Bottom right quadrant: Churches East.

Churches dominated the nominations, so we split them into two groups, drawing a dividing line just west of Downtown. So Church of the Epiphany (Downtown) and St. Mary of the Mount (Mount Washington) are in the east category, while St. Teresa of Avila (Ross) and St. Joan of Arc (South Park) are on the western side.

Click here to download and print a PDF version of the bracket.

Fish Face-off

Now for voting. We’re giving you extra time in this first round so you have plenty of opportunity, including Ash Wednesday and the first Friday of Lent, for research.

Use this Google form below or vote here by 10 a.m. Monday, Feb. 19. The Sweet Sixteen will be posted Tuesday, Feb. 20.