Ultimate Fish Fry Bracket

Why Carnegie and Scott Township have a stronghold in the Ultimate Fish Fry bracket

“People are obsessed with fish. They want it any way you can get it.”

Scott, Carnegie fish fry locations
MJ slaby / the incline
MJ Slaby

Selling out of fish in mere hours. Hundreds of meals in one night.

The demand for fish this time of year in Pittsburgh isn’t unusual.

But map the fish fry locations for the Sweet Sixteen of the Ultimate Pittsburgh Fish Fry, and there are several clusters of fish strongholds — Pittsburgh, eastern boroughs, and Carnegie and neighboring Scott Township, the only towns to have more than one fish fry advance out of the first round of our bracket.

In Carnegie, Ancient Order of the Hibernians Division 32 Sean MacBride advanced among Fire Halls and Social Clubs, and Riley’s Pour House moved on in Eateries. In Scott Township, Saints Simon and Jude and Our Lady of Grace are facing off in the Churches West category.

Fish Fry sweet sixteen featured image
The incline illustration

So what is it about this area that makes fish frys so popular? The answers are ones you’ll hear across the region: Camaraderie. Tradition. Good food.

“It’s a good community atmosphere — everyone craves that,” said Erin King, volunteer coordinator for Our Lady of Grace, which serves 800 meals on a Lenten Friday. The customers and volunteers give it that atmosphere, she said, adding that so does the church’s pastor, Father Richard Infante, who shares small glasses of wine with people as they eat.

At Saints Simon and Jude Parish, Peggy Sembrat, who organizes the fish fry, said it’s really special to see multiple generations doing their part to make the fish fry happen. Parishioners and community members who come together to eat week after week.

It’s the camaraderie that bring people to the AOH fish fry at the Ukrainian American Citizens’ Club of Carnegie, agreed Tim Regan, the AOH chapter’s president. “People like to get together.” The fish fry gives them an opportunity to enjoy a night out with family and see old friends, he said.

A few blocks away, at Riley’s Pour House, owner Jim Riley said the restaurant has regular customers on different days. But on Friday, they all come in at once for fish. “Everybody loves the fish on Fridays”

A long-standing, tasty tradition

Fish frys are a Pittsburgh phenomenon, Regan said. “Especially in south Pittsburgh, fish frys have always been big.”

The AOH fish fry is known for its fresh, hand-breaded haddock, which is thinner and less fishy tasting, in Regan’s opinion. He’s the chef behind the added offering of baked fish. Sometimes, he said, the fish runs out in less than three hours.

“It’s been a tradition that we’ve had for so long,” King said, adding that Our Lady of Grace volunteers work like a well-oiled machine to cook and serve the hand-breaded fish and sides.

Saints Simon and Jude had nearly 400 order last Friday, Sembrat said, adding that people come for the quality food and the variety from fried and baked fish to shrimp to crab cakes. Last year, mint milkshakes were added for St. Patrick’s day, and they were so popular, they’ve been added to the menu. So far this year, the choices are chocolate or vanilla, but Sembrat said mint will be added as St. Patrick’s day gets closer.

And at Riley’s, the nominators stressed the portions, one calling it the “BIGGEST BEST FISH.” Riley said the cod comes baked, fried or batter-dipped. While always on the menu, orders for fish triple on fish Fridays, whether people are eating in or doing takeout.

“People are obsessed with fish. They want it any way you can get it,” Riley said.

Taste test and vote

Ultimate Pittsburgh Fish Fry bracket Sweet Sixteen

Ultimate Pittsburgh Fish Fry bracket Sweet Sixteen

(Check out the interactive Sweet Sixteen map here.)

Voting for the Sweet Sixteen ends at 10 a.m. Monday, Feb. 26. Vote here. This map shows the locations of the remaining contenders with details below. Hours listed are for Friday only.

Allegheny Elks #339

400 Cedar Ave. (Deutschtown)
5:30 to 8 p.m.
Menu

Ancient Order of Hibernians Division #32

302 Mansfield Blvd. (Carnegie)
4 to 7 p.m.
Menu

Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary

45 N. Sprague Ave. (Bellevue)
4 to 7 p.m.
Menu

Corpus Christi

803 Market St. (McKeesport)
10 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Menu

Holy Angels

408 Baldwin Road (Hays)
11 a.m. to 6:30 p.m.
Menu

Keith Heinritz Katering

209 Brinton Ave (Trafford)
10:30 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Menu

Kretzler’s Tavern

2240 Babcock Blvd (Ross)
11 a.m. to midnight
Menu

North Braddock VFD

1318 Wolfe Ave. (North Braddock)
10 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Menu

Our Lady of Grace

310 Kane Blvd. (Scott)
4:30 to 7 p.m. (3:30 to 7 p.m. March 30)
Menu

Riley’s Pour House

215 East Main St. (Carnegie)
11 a.m. to 11 p.m.
Menu

St. Joan of Arc

6470 Liberty Road (South Park)
11 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Menu

Saints Simon and Jude

1607 Greentree Road (Scott)
4 to 7 p.m.
Menu

St. Mary of the Mount

131 Bigham St. (Mount Washington)
4:30 to 7:30 p.m.
Menu

St. Maurice

2001 Ardmore Blvd. (Forest Hills)
3 to 7 p.m.
Menu

Swissvale VFD

7400 Irvine St. (Swissvale)
11 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Menu

Wholey’s Kitchen

1711 Penn Ave. (Strip District)
8 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Menu

Want some more? Explore other Ultimate Fish Fry Bracket stories.