Shooting at Tree of Life Synagogue

Pennsylvania passed gun reform. Will lawmakers do more after the Tree of Life massacre?

“I think the loss of moderates will hurt the chance for bipartisan work on many, many issues.”

Rep. Marguerite Quinn is flanked by gun reform supporters and Gov. Tom Wolf at the capitol building.

Rep. Marguerite Quinn is flanked by gun reform supporters and Gov. Tom Wolf at the capitol building.

Gov. Tom Wolf / Flick
Sarah Anne Hughes

HARRISBURG — Flanked by lawmakers and dozens of advocates, Gov. Tom Wolf gave his ceremonial signature to a bill that aims to keep firearms away from domestic abusers.

Act 79, formerly known as HB 2060, requires people with a misdemeanor domestic violence conviction or final protection from abuse order to relinquish firearms within 24 hours. Those people can no longer hand over weapons to family or friends. Wolf officially signed the bill Oct. 12.

That a piece of gun reform passed the Republican-controlled General Assembly seemed to surprise even those involved. Rep. Dan Frankel, a Democrat who represents Squirrel Hill in Pittsburgh, called it the most significant piece of gun legislation that’s been enacted during his 20 years in the House.

The bill won approval in both chambers before the Oct. 27 massacre of 11 Jews inside a Squirrel Hill synagogue by a gunman who police say had anti-Semitic beliefs and a semi-automatic weapon.

The mass shooting at Tree of Life will undoubtedly be invoked during debates on gun reform when the General Assembly returns next year. The question is: Will lawmakers actually pass anything?

Rep. Marguerite Quinn, a Republican from Bucks County who sponsored HB 2060, said now that the bill is enacted, she believes naysayers will realize what the legislation actually does.

That will help lawmakers next session as they decide what can and should pass, she said, adding that misinformation was “not just floated but targeted to members about this.”

“One can respect the Second Amendment, respect due process, respect the Constitution and make sure guns are not in the wrong hands,” she said.

Rep. Marguerite Quinn is flanked by gun reform supporters and Gov. Tom Wolf at the capitol building.

Rep. Marguerite Quinn is flanked by gun reform supporters and Gov. Tom Wolf at the capitol building.

Gov. Tom Wolf / Flick

The loss of moderates

Quinn, one of the lawmakers key to HB 2060’s passage, will not be back next session.

She gave up her House seat to run for state Senate and was defeated by a Democrat as part of a larger blue wave in Southeast Pa. Other moderate Republicans who have been supportive of gun reform, like Sen. Tom McGarrigle, also lost their elections.

Sen. Tom Killion, another moderate Republican from the Philly suburbs, introduced legislation similar to HB 2060 in the Senate. He also co-sponsored a “red flag” bill that would allow for the temporary revocation of firearms from people deemed a threat.

Killion said he sees a path forward for more gun reform and called HB 2060 a “model for what can be done with bipartisan support.” He also praised the grassroots efforts of groups like Moms Demand Action to pass the bill.

When the General Assembly returns in January for a new session, Killion said he will re-introduce the red flag bill. “Here in Pennsylvania, any time you have a bill that mentions the word ‘gun’ it’s an uphill battle,” he said. Both Killion and Quinn worked with the NRA, which was neutral on the domestic violence legislation, to pick up more votes.

“It’s just hard work,” he said of getting “common-sense” bills passed.

Shira Goodman of CeaseFirePA, a statewide organization that supports tougher firearms laws, said there’s a tendency to look for a single legislative solution to stop gun violence.

“We really need to have a wholesale, different conversation about how people get guns, what kind of guns are available, what we’re doing to monitor people who may be in trouble or in crisis,” she said. “And I think if we put a whole bunch of those things together, we are going to save lives.”

Goodman said advocates were hoping the red flag bill would pass this session. She noted that several studies have concluded such legislation has reduced suicides in states like Connecticut and Indiana.

“In Pennsylvania, it’s really easy to get a gun,” she said. “We need to rethink that. I hope passing the domestic violence bill will tell people we can have these conversations, we can debate these things on the floor, we can look at the evidence … and we can get something done.”

Still, it’s hard to imagine that the loss of moderate voices in the GOP caucuses won’t have an effect.

“I think the loss of moderates will hurt the chance for bipartisan work on many, many issues,” Quinn said. She noted the retirement of Rep. Ron Marsico, the Republican who chaired the House Judiciary Committee and brought HB 2060 up for a vote. Quinn said she told him “you showed integrity and guts to bring that up.”

“Losing a moderate voice on any issue,” she said, “it’s not a good way to go.”

Explore other Shooting at Tree of Life Synagogue stories.

We love you, Pittsburgh.

Looks like you’re the type of person who reads to the end of articles.

Because you love learning about Pittsburgh, you need our free morning newsletter, full of useful news, can’t-miss events, and everything else you need to know about our city.

It feels like we know each other.

It’s nice seeing you here, because we can’t do this without you.

Make our relevant, original, and actionable journalism possible by contributing now.

Let’s make it official.

Your support allows us to do great work like the article you just read, and we can’t do it without you.

Will you become a member today to help us for the long haul?

You’re the best.

Members often ask us how they can go the extra mile to help us. Your financial support makes this possible. Bringing your friends makes it fun.

Get your loved ones to sign up for our daily newsletter today.